Contemporary Western Christianity, and society in general, struggles to remain free from two insidious evils. And when moving away from either one, it’s possible to jump from the frying pan into the fire.

On one hand is the idea that everyone’s out to get you. Your parents, teachers, the government, and even God are just looking for you to mess up. As long as you toe the line perfectly you’re OK. But if you fail to live up to someone’s expectations you’re in trouble. Bad things that happen, such as sickness, poverty, or anything else undesirable, are your fault because you did something wrong. It’s the punishment mindset, and it is certain to wear you out.

The other extreme is no better. Nobody’s out to get you, but everyone owes you something. The rest of the world is primarily there for your benefit. If your life is uncomfortable or lacking in any way THEY are responsible. Your parents owe you an easy happy childhood. Your teachers owe you a good grade. The government owes you education, a job, and benefits. God owes you health and prosperity. The entitlement mentality is alive and well in our society and in the church, and it will end up seriously disappointing you.

In the Bible, Job’s friends displayed a combination of the punishment mindset and the entitlement mentality. When Job lost his livelihood, his children, and his health his friends were sure it was because Job had sinned: he was being punished. If Job had been living right he was entitled to protection, health, and wealth from God. Job called his friends “miserable comforters” in their inability to see beyond these understandable but immature ways of thinking. (Job 16:2)

Yet even Job had things he needed to learn. While we know that Satan had instigated Job’s troubles (Job 1 and 2), we see no evidence in the Bible that Job ever realized how God had placed him “on the spot” in front of the universe. God trusted Job enough to allow the enemy to throw his worst at him. In the end God displayed Himself to Job, but He never provided him an explanation of his troubles.

Job’s story demonstrates that health, wealth, and happiness are no evidence of godliness. And neither are sickness, poverty, and misery. Our lack of happiness is not punishment. And neither does God owe us good things.

So what’s the alternative to the entitlement mentality or the punishment mindset?

A Grownup Perspective

There are three parts to a mature, grownup perspective that provide a great antidote to the distorted evils of entitlement or punishment.

  1. Accept personal responsibility. There are some things God has placed within my power to choose and take charge of. He won’t do for me what He’s given me authority to do. Being a free moral agent can be a somewhat scary thing when you realize how much God has left up to us.
  2. Know we have an enemy. God is good, all the time. But there’s an enemy that hates Him, and us, and who will do all he can to “steal, kill, and destroy.” (John 10:10) Sometimes that shows itself in our messed up sinful world at large, and sometimes in very personal attacks.
  3. Remember that God’s in charge. The lesson Job finally learned is that God is bigger than we are. (Job 42:5-6) He doesn’t answer to us, but He sees and cares about us. And as New Testament Christians we know the end of the story: Jesus is going to win!

Seeing things from an eternal perspective is the best way to prevent an entitlement mentality or a punishment mindset.

If you’re feeling attacked and put down in some way, do as God directed Job to do, and look at the bigness of God. Go outside and look at the stars at night. Watch and listen to the ocean waves roar. Stand in awe at the expanse of endless prairie, a majestic mountain range, or the power of a thunderstorm. Remember that God made them all. He’s bigger than you, bigger than all that, and big enough to trust even when you can’t understand.

And perhaps the best way to remember this is the well-known serenity prayer:

God, grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change, the courage to change the things I can, and the wisdom to know the difference. Amen.

Your Turn: Where might you have fallen into an entitlement mentality or a punishment mindset? Do you see any alternative? Leave a comment below. 

Tweetables: why not share this post?

  • Here’s the mature alternative to both an entitlement mentality and a punishment mindset.   Tweet that.

Do you want to live FULLY ALIVE?

There are simple steps you can take EVERY DAY that will propel you forward in experiencing the kind of life you want, and that God wants for you physically, emotionally, relationally, and spiritually.

Get your FREE Resource Guide now: 7 Keys to Living Fully Alive – from the Inside Out.